For a vehicle to be eligible for buyback under California Lemon Law, there must be a defect, safety issue, or other problem that interferes with its regular usage. If the vehicle hasn't been repaired in a reasonable time, it is possible for you to receive compensation. A Lemon law buyback refers to the manufacturer repurchasing the vehicle from the consumer because of these unresolved defects.
If you’re struggling with a defective vehicle in California, don’t let the frustration overwhelm you. Take action today by reaching out to The Lemon Pros and consulting with our experienced California Lemon Law attorney. After resolving thousands of Lemon Law cases, we have confidence that we can get you the compensation you deserve. Whether you are hoping for a buyback or a new car, contact us today for a Lemon Law consultation.
It’s critical for you to understand your rights through Lemon Law buybacks so that manufacturers can't take advantage of you. In this blog, we will cover the definition of a lemon car, show you how the Lemon Law buyback program works, and explain the process.
For a car to be considered a lemon vehicle, there are certain factors that must be met. First, California's Lemon Law requires that a claim be filed within 18 months of taking ownership of the vehicle while it is still covered by a warranty. Additionally, there must be an unrepairable defect that affects its usage, performance, or safety.
The factory warranty is in place to cover any manufacturer defects during the eligible period. This warranty states that the manufacturer will take responsibility for repairing said defects. If they cannot hold up their end of the agreement, then the consumer has a right to compensation.
And while the manufacturer is entitled to some time to repair the defects, what is a reasonable number of attempts when it comes to these covered repairs? The dealership has thirty days to attempt a repair for each complaint before it becomes covered under the Lemon Law. That’s not counted consecutively, either. If you take your car into the shop five times for the same problem, the thirty-day count across all five of those visits.
Another thought to consider is all of the potential issues that could be considered a defect. This poses the question of what types of problems are covered by the Lemon Law. Mechanical failures, safety issues, structural defects, performance problems, and unresolved manufacturer recalls are just a few of the reasons for filing Lemon Law claims.
A California Lemon Law buyback is when the manufacturer repurchases the vehicle from the consumer because of defects that can’t be repaired. According to California Lemon Law, manufacturers are required to buy back vehicles that have unrepairable defects. The consumer is to be reimbursed for the purchase price or provided a replacement vehicle.
The average Lemon Law settlement in California may take up to 90 days. Depending on the details, it could be shorter or longer.
There are several different outcomes that can happen, including the following.
Because there’s always the chance that the claim could be denied, it’s best to get guidance from a qualified attorney before filing for a Lemon Law buyback. If the manufacturer disputes your Lemon Law claim or only offers a partial settlement, you want an expert on your team.
Oftentimes, people are hesitant to move forward with their Lemon Law claims because they are worried about how much a Lemon Law attorney could cost them. Every California Lemon Law attorney sets their own fees. However, our team charges nothing for the initial consultation, and ideally, we would strive to get the manufacturer to pay all your additional fees if you win, such as rental car expenses or towing bills. If you don’t get paid, neither do we. Set up a free consultation today.
While every Lemon Law buyback claim is different, here are the typical steps for the buyback process.
If the car has a recurring defect that can’t be repaired, documentation needs to be gathered. This documentation should include all of the dates of service, the technicians and staff who were spoken to, and the results.
The next step is to notify the manufacturer. The consumer must make the issue known to the manufacturer, or the Lemon Law attorney can file the necessary demand letter for you. At this point, it’s critical to have an experienced lawyer on your side.
If the manufacturer can’t offer any resolution for your Lemon Law buyback, it’s time to file the claim. A notification gets sent to the manufacturer detailing the problem and the history.
Based on the manufacturer’s informal dispute guidelines, most Lemon Law cases proceed to arbitration first. Arbitration is a form of dispute resolution that involves a neutral third party, called an arbitrator, who reviews the facts and makes a decision. In the Lemon Law buyback process, arbitration can help settle disagreements about whether your vehicle qualifies as a “lemon,” whether adequate repairs have been made or even the amount of compensation you’re owed.
If the case isn’t resolved this way, the consumer proceeds to litigation.
During litigation or arbitration, the consumer and manufacturer may reach an agreement for a buyback. This buyback process starts with the offer of the purchase price, taxes, registration fees, and other expenses involved.
After the finalization of the buyback agreement, the manufacturer gives the purchaser the compensation or the replacement car and the consumer returns the vehicle. The title, keys and any other documentation must be with the vehicle.
Through this process, you want to follow some helpful tips to move the settlement along and ensure you get everything you deserve. Here is the best advice from our top Lemon Law attorneys.
A good Lemon Law attorney is just an extension of you. They handle all of the back and forth with the manufacturer, so you don’t need to be as stressed about the Lemon Law buyback.
If you follow the tips stated above, you are well prepared for a Lemon Law buyback. You know what you deserve and you have a good lawyer working on your team. The next step is to consider the buyback offer and whether you should accept it.
Here are some possible offers you may expect:
Purchase price: A fair buyback typically includes the reimbursement of the original purchase price of the faulty motor vehicle. This price covers the taxes, registration certificate, smog certification expenses, vehicle license fee and other costs associated with the purchase. There may also be reimbursement for other associated fees with the vehicle defect, such as towing fees, repair shop costs, and a rental car for the time that the faulty vehicle was in for multiple repair attempts.
Usage fee adjustment: Some manufacturers adjust the buyback with a usage fee. This is what the vehicle was worth and how much use the consumer got from it before the defect occurred. Mileage and time are both factors in this adjustment. All vehicle manufacturers have their own formula for deciding the Lemon Law buyback value.
Options for replacement vehicle: Instead of offering the buyback, the manufacturer may give the consumer a vehicle of equal value to resolve the Lemon Law dispute. This option is fair if the condition and market value are a good match.
Attorney fees and costs: In California, the manufacturer is required to pay the consumer’s attorney fees and other legal costs if the Lemon Law case is won. The fair buyback offer includes the amount paid to your qualified lemon car lawyer.
There’s always the option to negotiate with the manufacturer. You aren’t required to take its first offer. Having a professional Lemon Law attorney working for you helps this process go smoothly. In fact, manufacturers are far more willing to budge on terms when dealing with a lawyer.
If you've never had to work with an attorney before, you may be wondering how to choose a lawyer for a Lemon Law case. You need to do your homework. Start by following all of the recommendations given to you by the state of California. Any lawyer you choose must have a proven track record of winning and can give you references from past clients. It’s also good to check with friends and family to see if they have any recommendations.
Once the buyback is over, we hope that you never have to deal with a lemon vehicle again. By now, you’ve either purchased a new vehicle or are driving your replacement. The legal settlements should be long behind you and your attorney may have been paid by the manufacturer.
Keep in mind that there’s no law against filing subsequent Lemon Law cases if your next vehicle turns out to have defects as well. Each vehicle is considered independent from the other, so your rights apply to each one.
If you decide to keep the vehicle and take a cash and keep settlement, you can’t file any more claims for that lemon defect. Once you've agreed to keep Lemon Law buyback vehicles, you have also agreed that you are okay with future defects and problems.
By understanding the Lemon Law buyback process, you are ready to get every penny that you are entitled to. Any ignorance of the laws could mean you are missing out on valuable compensation.
Don’t attempt to file a Lemon Law buyback claim on your own. You need a reputable Lemon Law attorney on your team. Equip yourself with a lemon car lawyer in California for superior guidance and support. We at The Lemon Pros offer a free Lemon Law consultation and we have proven to be the experts in the industry.
The Lemon Pros know how to defend the rights of the consumer. Let us handle your lemon buyback in California. Visit our Lemon Law attorney practice in Beverly Hills today.
If your car qualifies under the Lemon Law, notify the manufacturer or dealer and request a replacement. If approved, they must provide a similar vehicle at no extra cost, minus a deduction for mileage before the first repair attempt.
Changes have been made recently to the used car Lemon laws in California, requiring there to be a manufacturer's warranty on the vehicle for coverage to apply. Aside from these changes, nothing has been altered with the new car coverage.
A manufacturer buyback means the automaker buys back a vehicle from the owner, usually due to persistent defects or safety issues. It often happens under a Lemon Law or warranty claim. You return the vehicle to the manufacturer in exchange for compensation or a replacement car.
A refund is offered based on the purchase price minus the mileage offset (miles driven before the defect started). There can be other incidental costs included, such as sales tax, registration and towing bills or rental car fees. A Lemon Law buyback calculator can help you determine how much you may be owed.
If the manufacturer refuses to honor the terms set by arbitration or fails to meet the court's requirements for a buyback or replacement, further legal action is required. You need to enforce your rights with the help of a qualified Lemon Law attorney.
This branded title means that the car was repurchased by the manufacturer because it had defects that couldn't be fixed. It serves as a warning to buyers that the car may still have defects, but can usually be found at a lower price than a comparable car without the branding. We recommend reading the vehicle history report to learn about the car's past before buying it.
Phone: (855) 725-2446
Email: [email protected]
We have an excellent success record in representing consumers just like you! We are award winning attorneys, but that has not gotten to our heads. We are attorneys who care and give personalized attention to each and every client, our attorneys directly handle your claim.
© Lemon Pros © 2025. All rights reserved.
Powered by GLP Marketing
